Step-by-Step—Class 9

Last updated on 2025-11-07 at 11:38 EST (UTC-05:00)

From Vacuum Tubes to Transistors: A Personal Reflection on the Building Blocks of Modern Electronics

Every once in a while, I come across a presentation that reminds me just how remarkable our journey in electronics has been. Al Penney’s “Diodes, Transistors and Tubes”, class 9 in the RAC Basic Qualification Course, is one of those — a concise, clear walk-through the history and physics that underpin virtually everything we take for granted in modern technology. [1]

For anyone who’s ever built a circuit, troubleshot a control system, or simply wondered how a radio turns electromagnetic waves into sound, Al’s lecture is a reminder that the devices we use daily rest on a few elegant physical principles.

Atoms, Electrons, and the Dance of Conductivity

Al starts where all good electronics stories should: the atom. Protons, neutrons, and electrons — familiar from high school physics — become the players in a complex dance that determines whether a material is a conductor, an insulator, or something in between.

Semiconductors sit in that fascinating “in-between” zone. By carefully introducing impurities, or doping, engineers can coax silicon or germanium into behaving predictably — letting electrons move when we want them to and stopping them when we don’t. That’s the foundation of everything from radio detectors to modern CPUs.

The Simple Genius of the Diode

The humble semiconductor diode, as Al explains, is just a P–N junction that lets current flow one way but not the other.

It’s the electronic equivalent of a check valve — elegantly simple, profoundly useful. With that one device, we can rectify AC into DC, demodulate radio signals, or stabilize voltage with a Zener diode.

I’ve always appreciated how intuitively physical these analogies are. Whether you think of diodes as electrical check valves or semiconductors as engineered crystals, they connect the abstract world of physics with the very real world of current and voltage.

Transistors: The Revolution in a Grain of Germanium

Then came the transistor — arguably the most transformative invention of the twentieth century. Al’s slides capture both the historical significance and the practical brilliance of that moment in 1947 when Bardeen and Brattain’s point-contact transistor first amplified a signal.

Before that, we relied on vacuum tubes: glowing, fragile, power-hungry devices that filled radio chassis and computer rooms.

The transistor changed everything. It was small, efficient, rugged — and as Al notes, it enabled everything from portable radios to the computers that now run our world.

As someone who’s spent a career around control systems and functional safety, I find the transistor’s evolution from that sliver of germanium to today’s silicon MOSFETs a story of both science and engineering perseverance. Billions of transistors now sit on a chip smaller than your fingernail — each one still following the same basic principles first demonstrated in a Bell Labs lab bench.

Amplifiers and the Art of Control

One of Al’s most practical sections deals with amplification.

Whether we’re talking about boosting a microphone signal, driving a loudspeaker, or switching a safety relay, the amplifier’s purpose is the same — to make a small signal powerful enough to do useful work.

Transistors and FETs handle this task differently, but the core idea is universal: use a small input to control a larger output. In machinery safety and control, this principle is evident everywhere — from sensor conditioning to PLC inputs and output stages, as well as pneumatics and hydraulics.

Reflections on a Legacy of Innovation

Al’s presentation closes with a nod to vacuum tubes — those glowing ancestors of the solid-state devices we know today. While they’ve been mostly replaced, they still hold a special place in audio and RF engineering for their distinctive performance characteristics.

Vacuum tubes are still commonly used in specialized radio applications, particularly in high-power RF transmitters, including commercial radio and television broadcasting, amateur radio, and military communication systems. Their ability to handle high voltages, high power levels, and their linear amplification characteristics make them preferred in these settings where solid-state devices may be less reliable or unable to perform as well. Vacuum tubes are also valued for their durability in harsh environments, such as those with radiation or electromagnetic pulses (EMP), which is particularly important for military and aerospace applications.

Key Radio Applications of Vacuum Tubes Today

• High-Power Radio Transmitters: Commercial broadcast stations still use vacuum tubes for final power amplification due to their capacity to handle large RF power loads.
• Amateur Radio Equipment: Many ham radio operators prefer tube-based transmitters for their superior signal handling, natural overload tolerance, and call sign authenticity in traditional equipment.
• Military Communications: Vacuum tubes are preferred in certain military radios because of their robustness against EMP and radiation, ensuring reliable operation under extreme conditions.
• Specialized Scientific and Industrial RF Systems: Vacuum tubes are used in some radar, industrial RF heating, and scientific instruments requiring high voltage and power.

Additional Contemporary Uses Related to Radio

• Vacuum tubes find niche roles in audio amplification equipment connected to radio receivers due to their characteristic sound.
• Vacuum tube audiophile amplifiers are increasingly common, where their soft roll off when over-driven yield a much better sound than the harsh clipping that transistors give under similar conditions.
• Some hybrid designs combine vacuum tube stages with solid-state components in modern radio equipment.

Thus, while transistors have largely replaced vacuum tubes in most consumer electronics, vacuum tubes remain essential in applications where their unique electrical and physical properties provide advantages that solid-state devices cannot fully match [5][6][7][8].

Reading through this material reminded me that understanding where our technology comes from isn’t just nostalgic — it’s essential. Whether we’re designing safety systems, writing standards, or just tinkering in the shop, the principles that Al Penney lays out are as relevant today as they were when the first transistor clicked into life.

In short: the story of diodes, transistors, and tubes isn’t just about components — it’s about curiosity, experimentation, and the human drive to control and harness electricity.

Thanks, Al Penney (VO1NO), for reminding us how far we’ve come — and how much of that journey is still worth exploring.

---

Bibliography

[1] A. Penney, ‘Chapter 9 – Diodes, Transistors, and Tubes’, Radio Amateurs of Canada, Canada, Nov. 02, 2025. Accessed: Nov. 02, 2025. [Online]. Available: https://www.rac.ca/

[2] J. T. Rubin, ‘The Invention of the Transistor’. Accessed: Oct. 29, 2025. [Online]. Available: https://www.juliantrubin.com/bigten/transistorexperiments.html

[3] ‘Vintage 1940s Operadio Tube Amplifier Guitar Lap Steel Amp 5641 Speaker’, Worthpoint.com. Accessed: Nov. 01, 2025. [Online]. Available: https://www.worthpoint.com/worthopedia/vintage-1940s-operadio-tube-amplifier-4596304184

[4] A. Singh, ‘Types of Transistors: Classification (BJT, JFET, MOSFET & IGBT)’, Hackatronic. Accessed: Nov. 01, 2025. [Online]. Available: https://www.hackatronic.com/types-of-transistors-classification-bjt-jfet-mosfet-igbt/

[5] Vacuum Tubes: Complete Guide to Types, Applications & … https://www.blikai.com/blog/vacuumtube/vacuum-tubes-complete-guide-to-types-applications-modern-roles

[6] Are Vacuum Tubes Still Used (& What Are They Used for)? https://pentalabs.com/blogs/tube-talk/are-vacuum-tubes-still-used

[7] When Old is Gold: Harnessing the Power of Vintage … https://www.radiodesigngroup.com/blog/when-old-is-gold-harnessing-the-power-of-vintage-technology-for-modern-applications

[8] Vacuum Tube Market Size & Share 2025-2032 https://www.360iresearch.com/library/intelligence/vacuum-tube

[9] Brief Overview of Vacuum Tubes and Circuits https://www.bristolwatch.com/science/vacuum_tubes.htm

[10] Vacuum tubes and modern uses for them : r/ECE https://www.reddit.com/r/ECE/comments/4hmi03/vacuum_tubes_and_modern_uses_for_them/

[11] List of vacuum tubes https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_vacuum_tubes

[12] Modern Radio Technology Comparison to Tube Radio https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GVXwsdsIyiI

[13] Unlocking the Future of Vacuum Tube: Growth and Trends … https://www.marketreportanalytics.com/reports/vacuum-tube-376095

[14] H. W. Silver, ‘Vacuum Tubes’, Nuts and Volts Magazine, no. November, pp. 8–11, 2017. Accessed: Nov. 01, 2025. [Online]. Available: https://www.nutsvolts.com/magazine/article/vacuum-tubes

[15] ‘Oilily A88 Vacuum Tube Integrated Amplifier, 45W+45W Class AB, EL34/KT88 Tube Amplifier with Triode & Ultra-Linear Mode, External Bias Adjustment, High-Fidelity Sound for Audiophiles (Black)’, Tube Amplifier Reviews. Accessed: Nov. 01, 2025. [Online]. Available: https://tubeamplifierreviews.com/oilily-a88-vacuum-tube-integrated-amplifier-45w45w-class-ab-el34-kt88-tube-amplifier-with-triode-ultra-linear-mode-external-bias-adjustment-high-fidelity-sound-for-audiophiles-black/